The purpose of this paper is twofold: (1) to understand how knowledge management failed to fulfil its promises and became a blurred field of research that gets increasingly diluted in adjacent fields, a catch phrase referring to an eclectic group of intangible phenomena related to learning and roughly to any organizational situations using the word ‘knowledge’; (2) to explore how the use a meta-theoretical analysis may suggest a way forward that moves away from eclectics to unity and highlight the potential KM holds for organizations striving to manage organizational knowledge within turbulent times. Considering the persistence of the conventional rational-cognitive obsession with recipes and the slicing and dicing of organizational knowledge in well-defined, circumscribed, and quasi-observable sub-domains, is timely. This widely spread inclination in objectifying and reifying knowledge fails to help organizations navigate the complex business environment of this first quarter of the 21st Century. Contemporary organizations are compelled to manage knowledge within a VUCA or BANI world. More than ever, firms must consider holistic perspectives enabling the management of an ambiguous and elusive organizational knowledge, while acknowledging the complexity or crisis state of our current world. Practitioners and scholars must go beyond the simplified assumptions currently available in mainstream literature. The following research question guides the study: What does a meta-theoretical study about the evolution of knowledge management reveal on its inherent ontological and epistemological assumptions, and how can this support scholars and practitioners to make most of a VUCA context? Through a meta-theoretical analysis, this paper endeavours to highlight how the field has come to this situation. It attempts to refocus the audience attention on the kernel of organizational knowledge, mechanisms, and dynamics. Meta-theoretical analyses on knowledge management are rare provided that the field is taken for granted and that trends seems to define the field and how it evolves.